The futility of classifying ourselves by race
July 11th, 2007What does it mean to be Latino of African-American? The author of this article rightly notes that many people, rather than identifying themselves with just one racial or ethnic identity, instead feel that they belong to three: their mother’s, their father’s and their own unique blend of heritage and experience. For most people, that’s fine - but when you’re a presidential candidate, there is often pressure to pick a side.
New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson has received criticism from both sides of the spectrum — for being too Latino, or not Latino enough. Some claim he tried to hide his Latino roots behind his “gringo” last name. Others feel he flaunts his Latino heritage too much, or only at politically convenient times. Some fault him for trying too hard to capitalize on being the “Latino candidate,” while others criticize him for running as an “American candidate, not a Hispanic candidate.”
He speaks Spanish fluently and was chairman of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus — and yet a recent poll showed that many Latino voters still do not realize there is a Latino candidate for president.
Richardson’s experience is echoed every day in middle school hallways and cafeterias across the nation. People want him to choose between one side or the other. What are you — Latino or American? And what about you, Barack Obama — are you black or white?
Obama, son of a black Kenyan father and white Midwestern mother, has been challenged on the same issues. Is he capitalizing on his blackness? Is he trying to “act white”? Is he too black, or not black enough? Too white, or not white enough?
In presidential politics, as in middle school cafeterias, there is overwhelming pressure to choose one side over the other. But the truth is, Bill Richardson and Barack Obama, like all bicultural or multicultural individuals, do not need to hide or deny — or, alternatively, over-inflate — one heritage at the expense of the other.
The two sides of their cultural heritage are not mutually exclusive.




